Say, What Is Music About?
Alright, I know this is being posted on Say What About Music, so if you can ignore the tremendously trite pun in the title, this article may have a chance at holding your interest. However, I'm not making any promises, because this is the internet after all…
So what the Hell is going on with music, and don't worry I'm not going spit out an excruciatingly long diatribe about the deteriorating state of the current music industry, and how everything you thought you knew about selling music is completely wrong, and how the major labels are picking on the little guy and ruining it for everyone, and why my personal opinion of the business is the only correct view, and everybody should bow down and worship me as their new buzzword spewing guru. When I say music, I mean exactly that, just music.
One evening during my daily commute courtesy of Metrotransit, a discarded newspaper sat next to me. Some dude in a GQ shirt stood in front of an expensive microphone on the cover. Apparently this particular dude won American Idol. I decided to take the article's word for it because I had no idea. I don't own a properly working television, and I am quite comfortable with that fact. The article had some pretty harsh things to say about the dude in question, and I blindly agreed because I think American Idol is an utterly inane dog and pony show designed to perpetuate corporate greed, but then I began to think. Why do I hate American Idol so much?
A lot of time goes into making American Idol. All of the singers, promoters, mixing engineers, session players, lighting technicians, and producers are hardworking and skilled at what they do, so how could that gigantic pool of talent create something so vapid? The answer may be in a words of a philosopher I somewhat despise named Immanuel Kant. "There are two things that don't have to mean anything, one is music and the other is laughter."
In the past century alone, music has evolved and changed into so many appreciated genres that the theory of a universal aesthetic has been thoroughly debunked. Proof of this is evident by the existence of the atonal era, avant-garde jazz, no-wave punk, and Kenny G. All of those examples are not exactly everyone's cup of tea, but they all have legions of listeners.
Now there is a perfectly good reason for this; music is split into two categories: art and entertainment. These two factions make up what I like to call the Personal Preference Venn Diagram. Each personal preference will vary.
Don't panic people, not all music is meant to have a deeper meaning, and believe me, most modern pop music doesn't, but that's not to say all pop music is devoid of artistic merit. With that on the table, not all music intended to be art is all that great either. To me, labels like art and entertainment are not measurements of quality; they are descriptions of intention and nothing more. I'm not saying that the categories are rigid or polar opposites, because that is simply not the truth. Art can be entertaining, and entertainment can be artful. There are no absolutes. Some music comments on human emotion or contains a sharp political statement, and some music just wants to make people dance. There is nothing wrong with any of it.
People need to stop caring about what other people think. Just because I loathe American Idol doesn't mean other people can't love it. If you don't dig the latest and greatest buzz band that all the indie snobs are drooling over, that's fine. If you want to belt Lady Gaga lyrics at the top of your lungs while driving, go for it. If all you want to do next weekend is listen to Sgt. Peppers in a room by yourself, be my guest, but most importantly, if you can't stand a certain song, don't listen to it. Find your song. Find what pulls your heartstrings and cherish it. Don't let anyone else tell you what to like because that, my friends, is what music is about.
Written by: Pat Dougherty for SayWAM



Due to the current state of the music industry, I have to participate in social media, but that doesn't mean I can't have fun with it sometimes.
It's a well known fact of the internet that I have a Facebook. I use it mainly as my promotion whore because I can't figure out Twitter, and I don't mean I can't figure out Twitter in the 60 year old man sense, which would cause me to ask questions like, " What's a Kanye West?" or "What are you kids doing on the Twitter anyway?" I just haven't found a way to use it effectively.
Facebook is just as pointless as the rest of them, but it can also be the most enjoyable. Besides commenting "First!" on wall arguments that are already 15 posts long, I also do things like this...


Godspeed your crazy punk genius!
I wasn't fortunate enough to know Jay personally, but I've been a fan for quite sometime. With all the cheats and tricks the music industry plays on us, Jay Reatard was exactly what we needed... a great songwriter who didn't take kindly to nonsense.
I recently saw him in Chicago. Like most punk rockers he had the "fuck you" attitude nailed down, but few had his raw emotion and songwriting prowess to back it up. His live show was a blitzkrieg of noise and energy, and I loved every minute of it.
I'm not going to spout off cliches about how only the good die young and I'm certainly not going to speculate how he died, but I will say this... They just don't make 'em like that anymore.
We miss you Jay!




This is one of my favorite days of the year...
The family, the friends, the food, the football. I needed one more 'f' in there for some solid alliteration, and yes, I am aware that despite my use of poetic devices the above is only a sentence fragment.
Now is not the time for tangents. Now is the time to give thanks, relax, and eat yourself into a coma (Yay America!). I myself am thankful for a lot of things: I'm thankful for the roof over my head, I'm thankful for good music to listen to, I'm thankful for my family and friends, but most importantly I'm thankful for all of you!
To everyone who as helped out Radio Noir by donating, Thank you!
To everyone who reads this nerdy collection of musings everyday, Thank you!
To all the people who consistently come to Second-Hand Opera shows and scream along with us, Thank You!
Have a safe and happy holiday. I'll see you all next week, and don't forget to call your mothers!
And rest assured, I'm eating at the kids' table. Those guys know how to party!




You guys were awesome!
Hmm should I really say guys?
Last night The Second-Hand Opera played at The Pulse, which is a venue on Saint Kate's campus.
College shows are always a mixed bag. You either get state-of-the-art sound and an apathetic audience, or a great audience with some pretty lack luster sound.
The sound was alright, but the audience was great! That even includes all the smart ass comments yelled out by Mr. John 'Cosmo' Kramer.
It was interesting performing on an all girls campus. I've been on the road enough times to become immune to the "You boys ain't from around here" look, but that look was never more obvious than last night. It made me a bit nervous, mainly because I didn't know what to think...
In all fairness, I had nothing to be nervous about. It was a very relaxing environment to play in, and the student body was really nice. A few of them hung out after the show to chat, and I always enjoy that. Yeah I know, I rhymed... I'm a tool.
The food they served us was a lot better than any college food I remembered and generous portions taboot. My only complaint for the night was my amp's behavior. It had a few moments of feedback, but only during the heavy songs so I don't think anybody could tell. All in all, great night!
The paycheck wasn't bad either...
I'm kidding of course. I want to thank every student at Saint Kate's, it was nice meeting you!

A Fender Rhodes is very heavy...
The gentlemen of Hotel San Sebastian came in waves. Foster arrived last, but he had to find a way to get off work, and I think he biked to our studio, which is badass.
The group had to dismantle their perfectly played Tetris game of gear they had assembled in the back of the car. Then carry it down a creaky set of stairs. They had a lot of unique instruments, and by unique I mean large in size. Although Foster's guitar is pretty cool looking.
The downtime conversation was really fun, even though the participants were mostly Woody and I. We talked about how every band in The Cities usually ends up playing with one another, and how we as artists naturally end up playing with the same bands night in and night out (whether we like it or not).
We all long for change, so expect see more Hotel San Sebastian/ Second-Hand Opera bills in the future, and perhaps the new Hotel album will be recorded at the Saint Paul Opera House...
I think I should explain something about the podcast. My opening line was, "I'm not sure if i want to edit that in post. I think I want to keep it in." Unfortunately what I was referencing got edited in post. Before we went on air, I advised everyone to keep silent when the theme song kicks in, because that means we're live.
As soon as I finished that sentence, Alex said something to the degree of, "Oh so I shouldn't say anything like 'I'm really high." I cut him off because the opening notes of "Woodstock Emergency Pipe" came on halfway through his sentence.
In a nutshell, the first sound heard on the broadcast was, "I'm really high." We tookit out of the podcast, but for those listening live I hope you got a good laugh.
Thanks for coming on the show guys! Oh and to the good people at American Rag, I'm sorry about the "On The Rag" comment. Sometimes things are funnier in my head than aloud...

Nevermind that line is still funny.





Pat Dougherty
Wednesday, November 11th, 2009
If there's an artist who can take the ideals of punk, mix in the free styles of jazz, and create songs in a folk setting, Mr. Pat Dougherty can do it ten-fold.
Pat Dougherty is not only working on one full length album due this early Spring, but two more EPs, his very own record label, Keep in Touch Records (which happens to be our sister label), recording with Dave Afdahl on his album, staring in an indie Zombie film, touring all over the US of A and growing a beard.
This man, sporting the "This Machine Still Kills Facists" stickers on all his instruments, has started to make quite an impact on the Twin Cites music scene.
We have much to expect in the future from Pat Dougherty so please stay tuned to his music and business. You can read his blog here and his myspace page here.
Check out his music and come see him and Dave Afdahl with The Second-Hand Opera on December 9th at the Acadia Café!
Good stuff no? I think the jerk said it best...
Big thanks to the people at Rush Lake. I'm somebody now!


A midsize car pulled up to our studio. It was stuffed with a drum kit.


However I still have a few copies of the Soliloquies reissue, but act fast because I'm running out.





